Steak And Guinness Pie Recipe
This is a proper pie. Pastry on the sides and bottom, not just the top, and loaded with meltingly tender beef in a rich Guinness gravy. You won’t find a more hearty Guinness pie recipe around or a dish that better defines “comfort food” than this. Yes, please.
Unlock this recipe
Start Your Free Trial
Serves
4
Beef Shin
Onion
Carrot
Celery
Plain Flour
Guinness
Beef Stock
Black Treacle
Dried Bay Leaf
Egg
Olive Oil
Salt
Black Pepper
FOR THE PASTRY:
Plain Flour
English Mustard Powder
Cold Butter
Cold Water
TO SERVE:
Mashed Potato
Unlock Mob Premium
Did you like this recipe?
Leave a note
Notes (4)
P
Phoebe T.
7 days ago
10/10, added the mustard powder into the pastry - however I think it would be even tastier without
R
Ruby B.
21 days ago
didnt follow the pastry recipe but the filling is amazing. so so delicious and worth the long cook time. officially the best pie I’ve ever made
L
Laura D.
3 months ago
The pastry was a disaster. Followed measurements and steps exactly. It went rock hard in the fridge, when it reached room temperature it then stuck, crumbled and fell apart. I could roll it, but I couldn't get them move it. In the end I pressed pastry into the base of the tin and top of the pie just to get it done. Super disappointed.
M
Mob
3 months ago
·Admin
Hi Laura, that sounds frustrating — sorry it gave you such a hard time. It shouldn’t behave like that, so something’s definitely gone wrong. We’ll take another look at the recipe and see if we can tweak it to be more user-friendly. Appreciate you flagging it!
S
Sofie H.
7 months ago
(edited)
Currently cooking this and so far it’s looking exciting. BUT it’s very misleading that the recipe says 4 hour cook, when the method then instructs to cook the filling for a total of 3 hours (after the chopping of veggies and browning of meat, which takes at least 30 min) and then a complete cool and then chilling for at least 3 hours! So you have to start cooking AT LEAST 6 hours before you even put the pie in the oven 😅